Tuesday, January 17, 2006

No wonder we kill our goats.



Scapegoat: One that is made to bear the blame of others often as a way of distracting attention from the real causes.

It seems that we need to place blame on someone or people for various reasons. In my corporate life when something went wrong people always wanted to know who was responsible. Who can we blame? I guess it makes us feel better if we can make someone responsible for whatever troubles us. Peyton Manning made his offensive line the scapegoats for losing the game this weekend.

In some ways you could say Jesus was a scapegoat.

We like to kill our goats. It makes us feel better.

I recently watched the movie Dead Man Walking again. I did so through the eyes of a chaplain.

To me, scapegoating was the theme of the movie. Sean Penn’s character killed two young lovers and essentially made them scapegoats by loading all the sins committed against him by his own father. He then became the state’s scapegoat by being executed for all the pain and suffering he caused.


Someone has to pay for the sin, right?

Tonight I attended my second vigil in the past month at the church I serve where someone was being executed by the State of California. I met the family of the person being executed; we prayed for the victims; we prayed for the person being executed; we prayed for the prison guards; we prayed for the state; we prayed for each other; and then we laid hands on the family whose member was being executed and prayed for them. It was a very powerfu and eye opening moment.

I heard a man speak who flew in from Pennsylvania. He is a retired Methodist pastor. Basically his son was unlocking the door to his apartment and his next door neighbor was high on cocaine and extremely paranoid shot and killed the young man. The retired pastor came to speak against the death penalty. He explained that he was filled with rage over his son’s death and so he prayed to God to help him. After about a year he finally came to the conclusion that the only way he could heal was to forgive the person who killed his son. The pastor explained that killing someone who killed someone to show that killing is wrong is wrong.

It seems like anytime time someone is killed a lot of innocent folks suffer.

On my way home, for all the normal human reasons, I realized I wasn’t “feeling” all that compassionate for the person being executed. As I wrestled with my emotions, I realized I wasn’t called by God to feel compassion. I was called to act with compassion. I wish I could say that I am that spirtually evolved but I am not. I have much soul searching and maturing to do spiritually.

Acting compassionate isn’t easy and is beyond difficult—it is an act of will, surrender and trust in something much greater than me. Like the pastor who spoke tonight, we need God to do in us what we cannot do for oursleves.


No wonder we kill our goats.

8 Comments:

Blogger Bar L. said...

I've been reading about this upcoming execution, and the other one that was all over the news...if that's what your refering to.

I can not imagine what it would be like to be with the family tonight. For their sake, I am so glad it was you that was there to pray with them.

God bless you, Rick.

1:39 AM  
Blogger New Life said...

Hi Laaayla,

I was just one of many folks there.

Honestly, this is new for me but it is a long tradition of the congregation.

Very heavy topic when I stop to think about it.

2:00 AM  
Blogger Donna G said...

Thanks for your honesty as this is a subject I struggle with. I too find it hard to "feel" compassion for someone who has dealt ruthelessly with others.

The minister who lost his son has it right, turn it over to God, let him be the Judge and the advocate.

7:41 AM  
Blogger Remnant Sons MC said...

just a question...

what is wrong with responsibility?
we seem to be willing to just blame our lack of responsibility with lack of compassion.

with our victim filled society, there needs to be some emphasis on personal responsibility.

it is always some one elses fault. I am a criminal becasue my mom did not love me. we cannot ececute this man who had others killed becasue he was to old, blind and deaf.

something does not line up here.

by the way, hope you are well in light of being away from your spouse.

8:01 AM  
Blogger New Life said...

Thanks for the comments.

Jeff, I agree, someome must be responsible for thier actions. I don't think that the issue folks struggle with is "responsibility" but with killing.

I too think this person should spend his life behind bars. Like a good friend said last night when he heard the news that some folks in Texas who ruthlessly killed someone received the death penalty, "Good" was his response.
I think it must be human nature to want to kill. Our human nature wants to do a lot of things, but Jesus Christ calls us beyond our human nature.

I met a guy the other day who would never say "shit" or drink a beer (at least in front of his church, but has no problem with executing people. Something seems tragic about that.

9:42 AM  
Blogger Remnant Sons MC said...

agreed.

6:18 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The question "What is wrong with responsibility?" imposes the responsibilty unto others. What about our own responsibility not to judge others?
We are not responsible for the actions of anyone but our own. But, the ego consciousness does not want us to take responsibilty for our own actions, that is why we need scapegoats. However, despite all the rationalizing we do, the laws of God will bring to us the experiences we need to encounter for our own spiritual growth. That's why Jesus said "Judge not, lest you aso be judged." He certainly didn't mean that God sits in judgment of us. That judgmental God is the god created by the ego. Jesus meant that our own actions sit in judgment of us for our Creator is love and compassion, not judgment.
When we look upon what someone did and make a judgment, we only see a very tiny portion of the picture, yet we presume to have sufficient knowledge of the situation to form this all inclusive judgment.
We have a choice in every situation: Will I follow (once again) the guidance of the ego to judge this situation, or will I follow the guidance of Christ?
If you consider these words as a judgment of you, they are not, for I send them with love. They merely convey what I have learned from my own quest for the truth through the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
Namaste.

8:06 AM  
Blogger Kelly said...

i was moved by your honesty, how we have to "act in compassion" even when we don't necessarily "feel compassion." why are we so feeling-driven? a lot of rationality is lost there.

our church had a conference this weekend, and i was on the leadership team for the teen venue. one morning, i gave the synapsis of the crimes of jeffery dahmer, and then showed a portion of his biography where he talks of his conversion in prison. we split off into small groups and discussed forgiveness.

these thoughts on acting in compassion would have changed the conversation..

thanks.

10:25 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 License.