Beware of religious know-it-alls.
Whatever happened to the saying, "There’s no such thing as a stupid question"?
When did questioning one’s faith, understanding of God, or one’s belief become wrong?
There seems to be a large segment of the church in this world that is afraid to wrestle with questions of faith. Where did the notion of getting everything right in matters of God and faith come from?
It seems when we become rigid in our beliefs that we often miss what the spirit of God may be intending in our midst. I think about the lady getting ready to be stoned to death for being caught in adultery. The "right" answer was to stone her to death. Plain and simple-- kill her. Yet Jesus, a good Jew, caused people to think and he caused folks to question their "right" belief.
In the story of Jesus healing on the Sabbath, the "right" answer was don’t heal on the Sabbath, yet once again Jesus forced folks to question their deeply held religious beliefs and challenged the "right" answers.
What are the "right beliefs" or "answers" that Jesus is challenging you to question?
I think we should question our beliefs or those beliefs that we have adopted through others. Jesus taught the religious folks of his day to look inside their hearts and allow God to "clean" the inside and work from there. When my cup is squeaky clean on the outside and I think I possess the "right" answers and I no longer have questions regarding my faith and life with God then there’s a good chance that I have become hardened, rigid, and lost the beauty of the mystery we call God.
Think about this, most every tragic event brought on by humans in history has been done by folks who were absolutely convinced that they were right.
Many have become masters at quoting the "law" to folks and just like in Jesus’ day this has put folks in bondage. Consider how women have been treated by those with the right answers in the church. Slavery, there were folks who had the right answer about slavery but look at folks are still suffering in this country as a result of having the "right answers". I don’t think having all the ‘right" answers or beliefs is what God wants from me.
I think God wants me to be faithful to struggle in prayer and community to discern God’s will. Just like the story found in the Gospel of John where Jesus instructed his Jewish audience, "Then Jesus turned to the Jews who had claimed to believe in him. "If you stick with this, living out what I tell you, you are my disciples for sure. Then you will experience for yourselves the truth, and the truth will free you."
Truth and the right answers are not something we possess with the "right belief" but rather truth and the answers come from struggling with the questions and attempting to be faithful to God. Even Jesus in his attempt to be faithful questioned God, particularly when things didn’t seem so good.
The very fact that you are asking the questions and struggling with issues of faith is probably a good indication that you are walking with God. Once you possess all the right answers, you no longer need to trust God, for you will think you are God and we all know what happens to those who want to "possess" the knowledge of good and evil.
Perhaps we are not called to be know-it-alls, but rather-- perhaps we are called to be faithful and seek to live our lives in the wonder, amazement, and mystery of Love.
10 Comments:
It is comforting to know that questioning indicates faithfulness. I truly always have more questions than answers, and when I realize maybe there is not a answer I truly rely on faith.
About a year ago I heard a wise man say, "Doubt is not the opposite of faith. Complacency is."
Thanks for continuing to write Rick.
I've been lurking for a while and love reading your thoughts.
I think that once you claim to know all the answers, you're probably much further off than you've ever been.
I used to be a know-it-all; or rather, I fight those tendencies all the time. Too often, I find my self-worth in displaying to others how much I know, that my analysis is the best, and that they should come to me for all of the answers to their questions. I enjoy learning, I enjoy teaching, I am rather enamored of sharing information with people, esp if they show an interest into what I'm interesting in. I'm selfish and egotistical like that.
However, when it gets down to it, when I really try to get all the answers about this God that I love and faithfully serve (most of the time), I find myself confounded by His nature, by His attributes, by how He talks about Himself, by how humans have tried to pigeonhole Him, and by my finite mind attempting to grasp His status as pure infinity. Thus, I have to forget that I'll never know it all and remember that He does. Thus, I don't have to anymore....
Thanks for the comments.
N, the more I know, the more I know how little I know. It is so true. I have a Masters in theology and find myself only pondering the question that much more. I relaize how much more I could know.
One thing I believe-- that is that I am loved and I attempt to live in that love.
Thanks
Thank you. Thank you for providing a forum where we can discuss such thoughts, issues, questions, and ideas, even though we really don't know what we're even talking about some days.
BTW, I know that you've recently reflected upon what your $50,000 seminary education is really actually worth. However, I've really been considering attending seminary myself for several reasons. My two primary choices are Biblical in the Philadephia area and Mars Hill in Seattle. Any comments on those? Any other places I should consider? Or should I stop thinking about going to seminary?
Dear N,
Can you email me and we can discuss? I think it all depends on what you want from your seminary experience. Let's talk about it some more.
Thanks!
As someone who's gotten into the habit of questioning everything, I agree. Only after I broke apart all of the assumptions I grew up with about religion did I finally have the freedom to begin discovering what I really thought.
And really, don't you think God would rather have us love Him by choice than because it's "the right thing to do?"
I wonder if I score any theologi-points for holding up as a badge of honor my 'know-nothing-ness'?
Not only do I not know it all, I find myself knowing less about anything all the time. Who knew?
Just tonight I was listening to Ben Folds' "Songs for Silverman" album and your post made me think of the album's first song... in a cheeky kind of way. :)
"You got smaller and the world got big...The more you knew we knew we didn't know sh*t...
"Why you gotta act like you know when you don't know? It's okay if you don't know everything.
Why you gotta act like you know when you don't know? It's okay if you don't know everything."
(Sorry for the silliness. I know it was a serious post... just wanted to share what was going on in my monkey mind.) Cheers.
Post a Comment
<< Home