Consciousness & Change: Don't tell me, show me.
Have you ever attempted to change someone’s mind or help someone "get it"? It is impossible isn’t it? I mean, for someone to truly change requires a revolution or evolution and an increased state of consciousness-- on one's part. This doesn’t occur over night and in a limited culture context. I cannot change someone; I can only change myself.
Ken Wilber says, in order for any sort of genuine transformation to occur--or any sort of real "revolution"--one must possess a new paradigm, which means that it must possess, not a new theory or worldview, but a new type of social practice, mode of production, concrete behavioral injunctions, or experimental exemplars. These social practices, injunctions, or exemplars--these new paradigms and methodologies--generate, enact, bring forth, and illumine new types of experiences, occasions, data, phenomena. Ken Wilber says that research suggests that somewhere around 25% of the population is traditional, 40% is modern, 20% postmodern, and only 2% or so is at integral or higher.
I think it is important to recognize that a new paradigm does not occur simply because one has more information. One has to be at a state of consciousness that he/she is willing to receive the new data. Think about your own life, most any paradigm shift occurred gradually and through time as you received more information and encountered new experiences. Perhaps some of your long held ideas of self or God changed as you moved from on cultural context to another.
Harvard professor Robert Kegan suggest five primary stage of consciousness.
Human beings develop through stages of consciousness, although not everyone achieves the higher levels. As new-born infants, we're unable to differentiate ourselves from our surroundings. We then begin to realise that our mothers are separate from us and that our bodies represent our boundaries. The third stage is socialization, where we examine the values of our tribe or culture and adopt those that resonate with us, so gaining our sense of identity. Adults who are at a lower stage are unable to see that maintaining good relationships is fundamental to their own well-being. Kegan's fourth stage is self-authoring consciousness, where we've recognized the validity of multiple viewpoints and that our culturally-derived values are insufficient, and so we formulate our own values - a quite outstanding mental achievement. At the fifth or self-transforming stage, we begin to recognize all ideologies as partial, and to seek to build relationships between them. In this way, not only do we approach our own potential, we accept our responsibility, as the most intelligent of living creatures, to look towards the welfare of the whole of our planet and its lifeforms - human, animal and environmental. (Source)
The only person I can change is myself. Thinking that I "get it" and wanting to fix others so they "get it" just like me is a sign that I haven't yet "got it." I can help others become more conscious more by what I do and less by what I say. The "doing" requires my having first evolved and changed with an understanding that I am continuing to evole. I need to remember this the next time I think I need to defend my postion in order to attempt to change another's mind. Don't tell me who you are or what you think, show me.
3 Comments:
Hmmm...this is one I'm gonna have to push-back on you a bit, brother.
I agree that, in the end, I am the only one I'm surely going to change - and even that is only by the grace of God and the power of the Holy Spirit.
But I've been asking myself this same question - why do we do so much of what we do, if we're sure that we won't change someone or something? If nothing's gonna change, why bother to even talk about stuff?
Admittedly, my former wife tried to change me in a number of ways, which failed completely - because I was unwilling to change. I know that I was unwilling to stop drinking, stealing money or lying to her (or anyone else) until I was ready to change (as a result of a LOT of pain). So I agree that willingness is a key.
But let's face it - in this very space, you have changed me - time and time again - just by your postings here. Your writings, your ideas, and your images of God, life and faith have both opened my mind and kicked my ass on a regular basis - and frequently that has happened regardless whether I wanted my ass kicked in that particular way or not.
Now, you could argue that the very fact that I'm here, and participating in the blogosphere, is evidence of my willingness to receive (or at least consider) new information...and I'll grant you that fact. But people throughout history - from Moses, to Jesus, to Augustine, to Martin Luther, to Martin Luther King - have all spoken out against evil, or for good - and they did so mostly when their message was unwelcome and undesired. By their speaking, and by their actions, they challenged people to change. They didn't change people - but by presenting new ideas, new information, new ways of seeing, they helped bring about change and transformation.
Just like you do. Just like I hope that I do (at least, on good days, when I'm not just spewing self-serving BS, which I'm still entirely capable of doing).
I'm not entirely disagreeing with you - but I am saying that the "I'm powerless over people, places and things" phrase can be a cop-out that says, "Because I'm powerless, I can't have any effect on anything, so I guess that doing nothing is acceptable."
I'm curious to see how others react...
this all sounds alot like the whole free will vs. election discussion...
people think that when you make the statement that you are powerless to change folks or to "save" them, that that means you just give up on 'em, but nothing could be further from the truth in my mind...
to me, it just means that u realize that folks have to decide for themselves & no amount of coercion is going to do it...
BUT
BUT, you never give up hope...
you simply know this to be true & continue to model what u know to be true...
it says that you do what u believe instead of say what u don't...{walk da walk}...
Post a Comment
<< Home